"Change is important, but not at all costs" and Change in (SXM) attitudes likely"
The headlines yesterday about Sarah's new attitude towards the Kingdom (Holland and Curacao in particular) put me in a blogging frame of mind. Someone beat me to it though, sort of, with this comment in Voodoo's previous post titled Vanity, Pride and Thin Skins. The writer is pretty much on target with my thoughts on the matter. There are a few things I want to add though, and because I think this story deserves a fresh blog page I will put them below here instead of in a comment there. I have also added links to related news on the Daily Herald website these past few days.
St. Maarten needs a New Status and to be free of Curacao, I fully support this and I think most people can agree with this point. The issue here is not whether St. Maarten will get New Status, but what form will it take. It's about vanity, pride and ego over rationality, practicality and wisdom.
Click here to Read More
____________________________________________________________
It has nothing to do with whether I like Sarah or not, I have met her a few times and she seems nice enough, and as far as I am aware, she does not appear to be as 'sketchy' as others in her Exco. My opinion and criticisms of Sarah and her govt are mainly based upon their actions and policies, unfortunately for those who choose to become public figures and politicians, their character and personality becomes a legitimate part of the discussion too. It is also the part they least want you, the public to see.
I sometimes sympathize with Sarah, she has to work with the Exco she has, not the one she might wish for, to quote Donny Rumsfeld. We all know of rumbles of discontent within the DP, the party is shaky and bursting with ego and power hungry addicts, all it takes is one defection or independent to fall.
But at the same time I hold her accountable too. Government at all costs has been her guide these past year and Status Apart at all costs is her new one. We are led by people who have no interest in reforming the political and judicial systems on the island because it lessens their powers and opens them up to accountability. They blame Curacao for just about everything that isn't working or dysfunctional while neglecting the fact they have been part of the Federal Govt for most of the last few decades.
Let's recap shall we?
EWE still in limbo despite two IC resolutions to preserve and protect it.
Massive destruction and pollution to the island's environment, and by extension the health of it's people.
No plans for garbage and sewage, also detrimental to the people's health.
An overloaded infrastructure and a delusional perception of 'progress'.
No Monument List legislation to protect and preserve the SXM's heritage. A few statue don't count, sorry.
No Marine Ordinance, last we heard they wanted to hear from the Fishermen again, about a year ago.
No Animal Protection Legislation, just talk and meetings, year after year. Blah Blah Blah.
No responsibility for its abused and orphaned children. Seriously folks, how long has this been going on now?
Little or no transparency or accountability, in or for anything.
A Code of Conduct that has been gathering dust. for 6 years.
No thought for climate change. Who better to have as friends when the sea level rises?
No thought for cleaner energies or energy conservation, the island is totally dependent upon oil, which extends to water and it's economic future. Not to mention food, we grow nothing.
A tourism policy centered on an American market at a time when their economy is under a big threat and failing to recognize the appeal of the Caribbean to Europeans, not only financially.
An overloaded, underfunded education system, which when connected with a similarly dysfunctional social system and poorly managed immigration and labor systems, leaves the youth of the island with little incentive or hope for a prosperous future in their own land.
A border point in ruins, a fish market / retail plaza with no tenants and a very expensive playground at Capt Hodges that has never opened. The VKS station planned there is also still nonexistent 3 months into the season.
St. Maarten robbed of owning it's own water plant, (watch and see, I wouldn't be surprised if Barendsen sells up in the not so distant future and makes a nice big profit.)
I could go on, further back to Fort Amsterdam, The Airport case, the decision to put a garbage dump in the middle of the salt pond, but I think you catch my drift. The point is, that while I wish St. Maarten had some inspirational leaders with integrity and vision, the truth is different. I do not have any faith of belief that the crowd running the place now can manage a country, let alone fix the problems it has, many they created, either by their actions and their genuine or false ignorance.
What cost is Sarah unwilling to pay for Status Apart? What cost is she willing to pay for it? Are the Dutch asking too much? Are they asking for something that the majority of people here want or not? Do you want change, reform and a fresh start? If the political / electoral system is not reformed, if transparency and accountability not enforced, if the justice and police systems don't get strengthened, then I have to say the future does not look fresh to me. It will be the same story in a different wrapper.
Change is worth the cost if the cost is corruption, cronyism, nepotism and fear in exchange for transparency, accountability and freedom of expression. Writers of this site cannot be open with their identity and many others are afraid to comment, even anonymously. This fear anhas to be confronted and the only way it will happen is if we have an open and transparent government.
Theo says that we can do it ourselves. I think I've already laid out the basic arguments against this point of view. His and Sarah's message is disingenuous and that is being polite. The DP Party logo sort of makes sense to me now, giving light so people will move on, sort of like moths, blinded and confused and getting burnt.
Status apart is not in question, it's going to happen. The question is, and it's one everybody who cares about this island and their family's future should be asking. What shape is it going to take? Do you want a fresh start or not?
I also think it's time for a new referendum on new status. it should include independence at one end and joining the BES islands in becoming a province at the other, with a few in between. I am growing tired of the xenophobic and nationalist hyperbole they hide their ego and power hungry agenda behind.
Times are changing Theo, the people want it, or at least most of those I know do, and you , Sarah, Roy and others should get used to it and accept instead of the struggling and resistance to it. Your good friend Lt. Governor Richards has said it too, its time for the so called leaders of this island to grow up and mature. Sadly, I don't think any of them capable of that.
Hady Nufyet
News Links below
NA demands IC meeting on WODC report - 18th February 2008
Theo: Dutch shouldn't impose conditions on St. Maarten - 15th February 2008
Duncan disappointed in Sarahs 'reaction - 15th February 2008
Balkenende appeals for positive attitude - 15th February 2008
Daily Herald Editorial - A call to leadership - 14th February 2008
How will St. Maarten ever get it right, Sarah wonders - 14th February 2008
St. Maarten too cooperative, now seen as enfant terrible - 14th February 2008
Balkenende surprised by Sarah's reaction - 14th February 2008
Balkenende: Progress needed before attaining country status - 13th February 2008
Constitutional changes could cost millions more - 13th February 2008
Professionalism must not be compromised in new status - 12th February 2008
Integrity, fighting corruption needs attention, says Dutch PM - 12th February 2008
Constitutional Change | Dutch Politics | Federal Politics | Island Politics | Hady Nufyet's blog | add new comment
Submitted by Hady Nufyet on Fri, 2008-02-15 09:56.
Recent comments
4 min 43 sec ago
21 min 23 sec ago
2 hours 51 min ago
2 hours 54 min ago
7 hours 50 min ago
7 hours 54 min ago
11 hours 4 min ago
13 hours 17 sec ago
17 hours 19 min ago
1 day 5 hours ago