
By Terry J. Peterson
"Anyone who votes against this budget, would be voting against the future of SXM"
-Roy Marlin, 2008 Draft Budget, Island Council Meeting, Dec 2007.
"The Island Council missed a golden opportunity"
-Sarah Wescott Williams, 2008 Draft Budget, Island Council Meeting, Dec 2007
The 2008 draft budget approved by the present administration is another bikini budget in which the more significant parts are concealed and the less significant parts are revealed. It is unfortunate that the current government would justify allocations to Tourism by suggesting that it is the future of Country St. Martin. It is alarming to think that school children, policy makers and many others may believe this hollow proposition. It would seem that this is the reason why our government finds it necessary to use tax payers’ money to train young St. Martiners to become dishwashers, bellboys and housekeepers in brand name hotels. What golden opportunity? The future of St. Martin is not tourism. The future of St. Martin is education! We need to build an educational system so that we could transact in knowledge production and knowledge export.
Click here to Read More
____________________________________________________________
Despite the claims of prioritized investment and allocation to Education and Youth, the fact is that the majority of funding for education and youth projects comes from external sources, charitable organizations and NGOs, for example, USONA. Also, as the Environmental Foundations have accurately pointed out, Environmental Education and Eco-Tourism is flagrantly absent from the budget. It is shameful that government can hardly finance the majority of youth and education projects, thus giving an impression that government cannot support youth and education. Already, many frustrated youth turn to criminal and deviant behaviors largely because of the daylight favoritism and “professional” nepotism that exists here. Why should they excel or take education seriously if most of the important jobs go to party hacks or enriches well-connected friends and family? If this government was serious about youth and education, the instrument which the Finance and Tourism Commissioner claims to be the cure for poverty and crime, he would have continued to increase budget allocation in those areas, especially environmental education, science and information technology. While he boasted giving millions for education, we need to scrutinize how much is really allocated from the coffers of the Island Territory. Everyone sees the benefits of education, even the poorest person, but to benefit from tourism one needs some assets even to eke a living selling in the Philipsburg Market. The tax base of tourism is also a liability to the Island. A 2005 document by the World Bank warns Caribbean governments to stop concessions and tax holidays to hotels because they do not stimulate economic growth. Instead, Caribbean governments should to begin to diversify tourism into eco-aqua, historical and socio-cultural and archaeological tourism.
Of course, more people can benefit from the tourist industry, especially the poor who cannot build hotels, cottages and guest houses. In almost every tourist market there are a number of accommodation alternatives. One of those, which has not been fully explored or supported by the current administration, is home tourism. In this sector, tourists choose to stay at the homes of local residents rather than the brand name posh hotels. There are tourists who only participate in this kind of tourism, because they are concerned about economic justice. Besides “seeking a more intimate property and the comfort of a homely and warm environment” (See “Small Hotels” by Alita Singh in Daily Herald, December 15, 2007), they also want their money to go directly to the local residents. This industry thrives in London and many other cities, and even in other islands like the Azores, located in the Atlantic sea. Countries like the Philippines export nurses to the USA, and in return Philippinos send billions of dollars back home. We are much closer to the USA than the Philippines, we can produce knowledge. The key to our survival is the production and exportation of knowledge at the University of St. Martin This is the only way we could become competitive in the world, truly reduce poverty and prevent “chaos in education.” Lester Thurow, economist, business expert and writer, has argued persuasively that Japan and China overtook the USA because it invested more in education and training. St. Martin will truly become autonomous when we upgrade USM to full University status and invest more money in quality education. We must also open the tourist market so that more people can reap its benefits by promoting home tourism and protecting our local guest houses. Presently, we are only re-creating pockets of discrimination in St. Martin because our beaches are practically all sold. A popular Calypsonian sang in 1994, “It’s a scandal the way they operate/ Building board walks and barricades/Like State within a State/For our people to enter/ For lunch or dinner/ We need reservations, passport and visa.” The chorus of the song continues in part, “Like an alien/In we own land/I feel like a stranger/And I sensing danger/We cannot sell out the whole Country.” This prophecy has become a reality in many Caribbean islands where condos, villas and gated communities are the hottest commodities on the Caribbean tourist market. As Victor Hugo once said, “music expresses that which cannot be said and on which it is impossible to be silent.” In this regard, it can be said with confidence that the case of Joan Verwoord is an insightful appraisal of tourism, education and economic justice in St. Martin.
Education and Youth | Environment | Heritage and Culture | Island Politics | Tourism | rebelwithoutapause's blog | add new comment
Submitted by rebelwithoutapause on Thu, 2007-12-27 12:44.
Recent comments
14 sec ago
3 hours 48 min ago
5 hours 1 min ago
9 hours 44 min ago
10 hours 11 min ago
17 hours 34 min ago
17 hours 47 min ago
18 hours 2 min ago
18 hours 3 min ago
18 hours 57 min ago